Monday, 2 March 2015

Benefit Rollerlash vs. my favourite mascara

I have used Mac Extreme Dimension mascara for years and I love it, but when I saw Benefit were releasing a new mascara I really wanted to give it a go. I also loved the packaging of the full size product too so I secretly wanted to love it before I even tried it anyway. I picked up the tester in Elle magazine (which I still haven't even read) to give it a go!

This brush is really similar to the Mac mascara as it has the short and long plastic bristles, but the difference of the Benefit one is that the brush is curved to go with the curve of your eyelashes. To me the formula seems pretty similar with these two mascaras and they do make my lashes longer and spreads them apart to make them look fuller. But I do think the Benefit mascara isn't as clumpy as the Mac one is sometimes, so it goes on a lot smoother. I have also found the Benefit mascara to not flake off throughout the day and lasts longer.

Unlike the 'They're Real' mascara I think this mascara is a lot easier to remove, I have always struggled trying to remove They're Real.. it's like tar! I have been removing this perfectly with my Garnier Micellar water so there is no need to buy some fancy remover to take this off. 

Before and After with Benefit Rolerlash:

Before and after with Mac 3D Dimension Mascara:

My eyelashes do look similar when using the products but overall I am actually liking the Benefit mascara better! It lasts much longer and doesn't flake all over my face. So this has definitely been a thumbs up for me! I'll be picking this up when it hits the stores, also excited to see the real packaging of the mascara too. What did you think of this mascara?

Follow me on Twitter or Instagram for live updates!



  1. Hi, just wanted to let you know that I've nominated you for 'The Versatile Blogger Award', you can see my post here:

    Amy ( x

  2. I've never tried a MAC Mascara but Benefit usually get it right for me in that department! Your brows are amazing, by the way! xx

    Magpie Jasmine

    1. I do love Mac mascaras but I love Rollerlash! xx


I love hearing what you think of a product too, whether you liked it or not! Please also feel free to leave a link to your blog so I can have a read of your posts too x

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
© Through New Eyes x - Beauty, Travel and Lifestyle Blog

This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services - Click here for information.

Blogger Template Created by pipdig